Skip to global navigation Skip to content Skip to search Skip to footer Skip to site map Access Key Legend
Global Navigation
Events
Search
Translate
Close
English English
JSO Facebook JSO Twitter JSO Instagram JSO YouTube
Open Navigation
Close Subnav
content
COJ.net > News > Detectives Make Quick Arrest in Deadly Mandarin Shooting
JSO News
Detectives Make Quick Arrest in Deadly Mandarin Shooting
November 04, 2025
Detectives arrested Donald Rentfrow Jr., 44, the morning of Tuesday, November 4, 2025, after he shot and killed a man in the Mandarin area Monday night.
 
Around 5:30 p.m. on Monday, November 3, 2025, District 3 patrol officers responded to a shooting on Rustic Green Court. When they arrived, they found 43-year-old Stephen Shahly in the garage; he had been shot and succumbed to his injuries at the scene.
 
Jacksonville Sheriff's Office (JSO) Homicide Unit detectives launched their investigation, interviewing witnesses and reviewing video surveillance footage. Using all the investigative tools available to them, detectives identified Rentfrow as the gunman. Investigators along with JSO's SWAT Team served a search warrant on his home early Tuesday morning.
 
Rentfrow was taken into custody, interviewed and ultimately arrested. He is currently behind bars in the John E. Goode Pretrial Detention Facility (Duval County jail).

To access the arrest report and booking photo, please visit the Published Media Requests page on JSO's Public Records Portal and search "M489276" in the Reference No. section. 

 

Share On Twitter Share On Facebook
footer
JaxSheriff Home
To Serve And Protect
In Partnership With Our Community
Vision
"To serve the citizens of Duval County by approaching our work with a service-oriented mindset, enforcing the law, promoting public safety, being transparent, and fostering a safer and more secure Jacksonville for all."
Follow Us
JSO Facebook JSO Twitter JSO Instagram JSO YouTube
Disclaimer And Privacy Policy | Equal Employment Opportunity Statement
Need Assistance? Emergency 9-1-1 (TTY Services Available) | Non-Emergency 904.630.0500 | General Information 904.630.7600
Accommodations for persons with disabilities are available upon request. Visit our accessibility page for more information. v1.12.10
Video Player Window
Close
Exit Youtube Player
Gallery Window Popup
Close Previous
Next
Exit Photo Gallery
Close Search
Search Results Close Search
The History of the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office Your Sheriff's Office
/Sheriffs-Office/History.aspx 11/6/2018 1:33:52 PM

/News/20231001-Consolidation-Anniversary.aspx 10/1/2023 4:38:56 PM
Application Process The Jacksonville Sheriff's Office offers unpaid internship opportunities to undergraduate students who are interested in a career in the law enforcement field. The program is designed to provide students with a comprehensive understanding of the operatio...
/Careers/Internship.aspx 11/22/2024 1:30:57 PM
JoinJSO.com Working as a civilian employee provides people the chance to serve their community in a number of ways. Civilians play a vital role in JSO’s success as a law enforcement agency. The following career choices are examples of the varied career paths available to a ci...
/Careers/Civilian.aspx 2/11/2019 11:13:56 AM

/News/2024-Police-Memorial-Day-Service.aspx 4/17/2024 10:00:34 AM
JOINJSO.com A career as a Court Bailiff Officer is more than a job, it is an excellent career path for those who want to protect others and develop a long lasting career in law enforcement. Court Bailiff Officers primarily provide protection and maintain order in the court...
/Careers/Court-Bailiff-Officer.aspx 2/11/2019 11:13:29 AM
JoinJSO.com Working as a civilian employee provides people the chance to serve their community in a number of ways. Civilians play a vital role in JSO’s success as a law enforcement agency. The Jacksonville Sheriff's Office Records and Identification Unit is a critical supp...
/Careers/Records.aspx 7/29/2019 11:43:50 AM

/News/2022-Police-Memorial-Day-Service.aspx 4/14/2022 1:30:12 PM
JoinJSO.com Choosing Police Dispatcher as a profession means that you enjoy a fast-paced, exciting environment in which to work. Many times, Police Dispatchers are the first to speak with a citizen during an emergency, and must provide accurate information to the citizen a...
/Careers/Dispatcher.aspx 2/11/2019 12:55:02 PM
Commonly Searched For:
Inmate SearchHistoryRegistrationSheriff
Exit Search
Access Key Legend
Most browsers support jumping to specific links by pressing access keys on your keyboard. On Windows, you can press ALT + Access Key (Chrome), ALT + Access Key + Enter (Internet Explorer) or ALT + Shift + Access Key (Firefox); on Macintosh, you can press Control + Option + Access Key (Safari, Firefox, and Chrome). All pages on this site use the following access keys:
Access Key 1 : Navigation
Access Key 2 : Page Content
Access Key 3 : Search
Access Key 4 : Footer
Access Key 5 : Site Map Access Key 6 : Access Key Legend Visitors using the JAWS screen reader 8 or above can navigate using the following keystrokes: H to cycle forward through the headings
Shift + H to cycle backwards through the headings
1 to navigate to the next level 1 heading (or a number between 1 and 6 to navigate to the next heading on this level)
Shift + 1 to navigate to the previous level 1 heading (or a number between 1 and 6 to navigate to the previous heading on this level)
Insert + F6 to provide a list of all headings
We are committed to meeting the guidelines set forth by the American with Disabilities Act (ADA), Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act, and Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG2). All pages on use structured semantic markup. H1 tags are used for main titles, H2 tags for subtitles. View the City of Jacksonville Americans with Disabilities Act Notice.
End Of Page